The “Perfect Penis” is the 1st Mr. Hankey’s Toy I’d call an “everyday dildo.” Its platinum silicone is easy to take: soft, fleshy, and skin-textured.
Unlike Hankey’s Toys’ other realistic silicone dildos, it comes in a more accessible size: 1.5 inches average diameter for the “small” size. I tested the Perfect Penis silicone dildo for vaginal vs. anal use:
The Run-Down:
Dildo with uber-realistic skin textures, in fleshy-soft silicone (or firm; you decide). 4 size options, from pretty-long (but not wide) to massive. A comfortable f*ck!
$130.90 at Mr. Hankey’s Toys (for size S)
Pros & Cons
Pros
- Very lifelike skin textures.
- Streamlined shape is easy to take.
- Body-safe platinum silicone.
- Made-to-order options: 4 firmnesses, 4 sizes, 24 colors, 1 color effect, Vac hole or no.
- Long length helpful for: anal probing, harness use, easier reach on a fucking machine, vaginal depth play & cervical stimulation.
Cons
- For vaginal use: Not dual-density silicone. Lower shaft is flexible.
- First-time buyers may be confused which density to choose. (75% Soft is most popular for all-but-XL+ toys.)
The Perfect Penis dildo is 100% platinum-cured, U.S. made silicone. It’s available in 4 sizes. I got the most-average size, “small,” which is still long: 6.5″ usable length and 8.75″ total length (including realistic testicles). Its girth is close to median penis size, expanding from from 4.4″ to 5″ circumference (1.4″ to 1.6″ diameters); and it has a 1.5″ wide × 1.3″ long head.
Contents
My Review Criteria
All body-safe, zero BS. I only recommend body-safe toys, no bullshit and no paid promos. If I wouldn’t give a toy to a close friend, then I won’t recommend it to you, either. I’ve tested over 1,080 vibrators, 530 dildos, and 165 butt plugs (and a plethora of cock rings, kink gear, and lubes!). Everyone’s preferences vary, so I rate vibrating toys by 1. power level and 2. rumbliness; and always describe how my personal tastes color my experience.
Perfect Penis Dildo Size
The Perfect Penis dildo small is close to real-human-peen median girth, expanding from 1.4 to 1.6 inches diameter. Other “small” size Hankey’s Toys are BIGGER: they run from 6 to 7.5 inches circumference, which is way above average for live members.
While I love a good stretch vaginally, my ass is more timid. The perfect penis there is smaller, more manageable, as I get my anal play on.
That’s why the Perfect Peen in small is more accessible for butt play for me. See it vs. most of my other Hankey’s Toys realistic dildos:
My Experience
“Perfect Penis” as a dildo name is as superlative as “the best vibrator.” You may not like what your friend likes; no single product works for everyone. But, there are general trends that fit *most* people.
And I appreciate that Hankey’s Toys gave the name to a dildo that’s genuinely bangin’ for good anal play. The Perfect Penis dildo’s streamlined shape, slightly popping ridge, and spot-on skin lines = it’s a sweet anal dildo.
The skin textures came through so well on this model. They’re not too raised, not draggy; but they are noticeable when I slow down and thrust this toy vaginally.
The ridge… lightly raised, just enough to feel its *bump* as it passes my G-spot. Not imposing; its primary goal isn’t G-spot play. Going deeper, ramming the Perfect Penis Dildo’ comfortable, soft head all the way back is the best for me vaginally.
I insert my favorite bullet vibrator into the Vac-hole option I choose when ordering the Perfect Penis Dildo. Bam, a hard orgasm after a few minutes’ thrusting.
I cleaned the Perfect Penis dildo well, then moved on to anal testing this “Perfect” dildo. (I knew I could always sanitize its silicone post-anal, too, if I wanted to switch holes later.) I stretched with the fantastic-ness of the small Egg Plug, wearing it for half an hour. Then, I was ready.
The Perfect Penis’ head slid in. It felt impressive. A little tightness, as I eased it deeper; till I could thrust back-and-forth a full inch. Prelubed with coconut oil, my butt was at ease with how this silicone glides. Just a touch of texture; those skin lines. And so easy to move. Mounted on my machine… now that’s fulfilling anal. My rectum’s small, so the Perfect Penis’ 6.5 inch length is absolutely probing the beginning of my sigmoid colon, as I let it thrust all the way in. It’s a weird feeling at first, honestly. You get used to it as the Perfect Penis continues moving; the 75% Soft silicone was the right choice here, because it’s so forgiving. I had my bullet vibe latched to my fingers, and nearly screamed when I came about 10 minutes in; I’d been edging by that point, letting it build up. 10/10 satisfying.
Mr. Hankey’s Toys’ Silicone
Hankey’s Toys now offers 5 different silicone densities in all their dildo listings. Silicone is unique because it’s the only body-safe sex toy material that can be soft—or can also be very firm!
- 40% Soft, about 00-30 Shore: The softest option, squishy in smaller (6″ or less circ.) toys. Choose 40% for more realism in thick toys: like when I got the smallest-size Goliath, I should’ve gotten 40% Soft.
- 75% Soft, about 00-50 Shore: Popular squeezable-fleshy density.
- Med Firm, 8–9A: The firmness of an erection, except with zero soft skin feel. Opt for it if you don’t want your silicone dildo to bend as you thrust.
- Extra Firm, ?A: The hardest silicone option, obviously! Choose if you want more pressure: Could be good for ultra-curved G- & P-spot toys like the Captain Hook dildo. I haven’t tried this density since I think Med Firm is already over-firm!
How to Use
How to Position
You can choose Vac-hole or No Vac-hole from the “Attachment Hole” dropdown when ordering a Perfect penis dildo, and that’ll make a big different in how you use the dildo.
Hankey’s Vac hole cavity is tighter than that of Doc J. Vac-U-Lock dildos, but Hankey’s hole will fit Vac-U attachments or most (less than 1″ wide) bullet vibrators.
The Vac-hole lets you position any Hankey’s Toy:
- On a fucking machine with Vac-peg attachment. (I have one for my Hismith Premium machine, pictured.) This is the laziest option for using Hankey’s Toys, and absolutely the way if you wanna get continuously pounded, without having to ride.
- There’s a suction cup attachment available, sold separately. Best for sticking onto horizontal surfaces, i.e., smooth flooring.
- On a harness with a Vac-U peg connector.
If you don’t go for the Vac hole, the Hankey’s Toys dildo will have a normal, flat base. For the Perfect Penis dildo size medium and up, a double-sided suction cup would make it stick to smooth floor / tile (but small size’s base is too small for the suction cup to latch on).
Care & Cleaning
To clean, just use your normal handsoap and scrub the Perfect Penis under running water from your sink.
It’s compatible with all lubricants. Using silicone lubricant will create more a film on the cured silicone, though, so it’s a pain to clean off, IMO.
Hankey’s Toys silicone can be stored with other platinum silicone dildos. (Don’t store it with cheap PVC or jelly toys.) The current blend of Hankey’s 75% Soft silicone is not too sticky, meaning it’s not exuding dimethicone “silicone oil” as much as, say, VixSkin dildos do. But, you might avoid storing a Hankey’s dildo directly touching any silicone-coated vibrator, since super-soft silicones can make thin vibe coats swell up and begin delaminating from the plastic motor core below.
Recap & Rating
Hankey’s Toys Perfect Penis Dildo (4 possible sizes) is dead-up excellent as an anal dildo, if you like realistic dongs. The ridge is stimulating, but not super-raised; so it glides better. The skin line texture is fantastic, so precisely captured. Pair it with coconut oil (or Sliquid Silk or X-Lube, as you please) and you’re good to go.
Since it’s very streamlined, it’s not a G-spot dildo / not a strong prostate stimulator. It’s for a smooth + skin feel thrust session, just easy in-and-out. That’s in the small size: it does come in XL sizes too. LG/XL and XXL are still the enormous SIZE FAN level the brand is known for. In those giganto sizes, probably opt for the 30% Soft Firmness option at checkout. (Silicone feels harder as it gets thicker).
For my holes, the 75% Soft firmness is best in the small Perfect Penis, imitating flesh most closely.
Shop Hankey’s Toys for the Perfect Penis with all options available.
| Feature | Rating (out of 5) |
|---|---|
| Fun per dollar value (if u like realistic dongs): Soft with super-real skin textures. Gently popping ridge, lots of length for deeper probing. With Vac-hole option, it’ll fit a bullet vibrator or attach to a sex machine connector.👍 Pricier than most realistics, but it’s U.S.-handmade platinum silicone. | 4.5 |
| User experience/ Ease of use: Love all the customization options. A+ skin textures. Glides extremely well with any lube. Head is stimulating but not overpowering. Deep probing feels great. Vac-hole add-on makes it attach to a dildo-machine with Vac connector. | 4.25 |
| Quality: Body-safe silicone, minimalist packaging with care instructions, great as long as you don’t expect a fancy box. | 5.0 |
| Silicone Feel: Excellent balanced density (75% Soft). Pretty darn fleshy. Not sticky (like many soft silicones are). Smooth ride. | 4.0 |
| Total | 4.7/10 |
| Dimensions | From 4.39″ to 5″ circumference × 6.5″ usable length = 1.6″ maximum diameter |
Perfect Penis Dildo
The Perfect Penis Dildo by Hankey's Toys: uber-realistic skin textures, in fleshy-soft silicone (or firm; you decide). 4 sizes! Tested for vaginal vs. anal use.
Product Brand: Hankey's Toys
4.6
Pros
- Very lifelike skin textures.
- Streamlined shape is easy to take.
- Body-safe platinum silicone.
- Made-to-order options: 4 firmnesses, 4 sizes, 24 colors, 1 color effect, Vac hole or no.
- Long length helpful for: anal probing, harness use, easier reach on a fucking machine, vaginal depth play & cervical stimulation.
Cons
- For vaginal use: Not dual-density silicone.
- First-time buyers may be confused which density to choose.
NOTE
Some suggest medium firm rather than 75% when using Hankey realistic dildos with F machines to reduce “floppiness” during anal thrusting. Your thoughts?
Right, I see the logic in that. The greater hardness would be a negative that outweighs the “less flop” for me, also because I prefer slower anal thrusting, so that also reduces flop with the 75% Soft. Very valid to prefer the medium-firm density, but I wouldn’t choose it personally.